Definition of cultural relativism although philosophically not very satisfactory see bidney 1953, pp. Herskovits definition of art is exceptionally broad. Published way back in 1941, this unprecedented chronicling of the racist academic procedures practiced by most white scholars peers into the subject of the retainment of an african cultural identity and draws. Melville herskovits, a wellknown anthropologist and student of boas, fur. Herskovits spent his long academic career at northwestern university, from 1927 until his death in 1963. Cultural relativism can be portrayed by the opposite of ethnocentrism. Melville jean herskovits september 10, 1895 february 25, 1963 was an american anthropologist who helped establish african and africanamerican studies in american academia.
Originally published in 1941, his unprecedented study of black history and culture recovered a rich african heritage in religious and secular life, the language and arts of the americas. The negro past and present explores the wartime contributions of melville herskovits, founder and chair of the first african studies program in the country, at northwestern university. Cultural relativism is the idea that a persons beliefs, values, and practices should be understood based on that persons own culture, rather than be judged against the criteria of another it was established as axiomatic in anthropological research by franz boas in the first few decades of the 20th century and later popularized by his students. Study on crosscultural adaptation of southeast asian. From the 1920s to the 1960s, herskovits confronted questions about race and culture in innovative and groundbreaking ways, controverted hierarchical ways of thinking about humanity, and underscored the value of human diversity. Take the case of melville herskovits, a jewishamerican anthropologist of slovak extraction who broke new ground in the definition and analysis of africanamerican culture. Herskovits drew from numerous social sciences to make his points, but he viewed culture as learned behavior and took an ethical position cultural relativism that precluded ethnocentric judgments. In their views, cross cultural adaption is the variant of cultural pattern, which is. Herskovitss two decades of research in the field of what could now be called black diaspora studies, preceding world war ii, is reflected in his wartime. California newsreel herskovits at the heart of blackness.
Evanspritchard economic elements employed enculturation euroamerican european. Almost fifty years ago melville herskovits set out to debunk the myth that black americans have no cultural past. Melville jean herskovits, an american anthropologist who was a student of franz boas at columbia university, became a leading student of acculturation and an outstanding teacher at northwestern university, where he founded the first u. The intellectual standard critiquing cultural relativism ther elucidated the theory. Herskovits was criticized for his views on both the formation of africanamerican subculture and cultural relativism.
This would include everything from childhood training. Radcliffebrown achieved admiralty island american analysis angita animals anthropology artist ashanti aspects of culture aurignacian basic behavior belief biological boas bushmen called complex concept cultural relativism custom dance derived e. This study became the starting point of his fundamental work on the classification of african cultures into culture areas, which appeared in preliminary form in. Similarly, melville herskovits, for a long time a missing figure in the annals of history of anthropology and one of the central protagonists of acculturation theory. Herskovits 18951963 employed physical anthropology and ethnography to undermine racist and hierarchical ways of thinking about humanity and to underscore the value of.
Herskovits at the heart of blackness follows melville herskovits historically significant efforts to connect african americans with africa, and interrogates the relationship between anthropological observer and subject. Cultural relativism of melville herskovits 141 man of science and a man of the world. His additional works include economic transition in africa, the human factor of changing africa, and life in a haitian valley. Cultural relativism might be easier in theory than in practice. He also considered himself to beand i think he wasa. Of all published articles, the following were the most read within the past 12 months.
Ethnocentrism is a slippery concept that different disciplines and individuals use in diverse, inconsistent, and incompatible ways. In other words, a persons judgment about what is right and wrong is determined by their cultural experiences. Reflective of the depth of his concern about the arts was his frequent emphasis on art as a cultural universal the search for beauty is universal in human experience 1955. Herskovits at the heart of blackness melville herskovits. The myth of the negro past by herskovits melville,j. In addition to this monograph, herskovits produced two other major contributions to the study of dahomey in collaboration with his wife, an outline of dahomaen religious belief 1933 and, much later, dahomean narrative.
Cultural relativism 2 california state university, northridge. Herskovits papers consist of the research data field notes, both handwritten and typed used for their seminal publications on both old and new world african cultures, manuscripts of their books and published articles, conference papers and materials relating to their careers. Melville jean herskovits, american anthropologist, was among the founders of african anthropology and african studies in the united states. Two points are central in understanding his conception of anthropology. Herskovits, frances herskovits, american journal of sociology 79, no. Cultural relativism, posits herskovits, begins with the notion that experience is mans primary connection to reality. Sep 18, 20 in the passage, cultural relativism and cultural values, melville herskovits explains why morality has no absolute identity and that it is a social and cultural phenomenon that varies according to the customs and beliefs of different cultural groups 2. Cultural relativism and cultural values by melville j. Ethnocentrism is usually defined as a kind of ethnic or cultural.
He also helped forge the concept of cultural relativism, particularly in his book man and his works. Cultural relativism is the idea that a persons beliefs, values, and practices should be understood based on that persons own culture, rather than be judged against the criteria of another. Take the case of melville herskovits, a jewishamerican anthropologist of slovak extraction who broke new ground in the definition. Published way back in 1941, this unprecedented chronicling of the racist academic procedures practiced by most white scholars peers into the subject of the retainment. Herskovits northwestern university d uring the past five years, the implications of cultural relativism have been considered at length in at least two books by philosophers and two by anthropologists. In addition, i address not one or two, but eleven arguments for cultural relativism, many of which contribute to its popularity but receive scant attention from its critics. Herskovits at the heart of blackness cultural relativism. Campbell points out in the introduction of herskovits s book. Herskovits northwestern university d uring the past five years, the implications of cultural relativism have been considered at length in at least two books by philosophers and two. It is through experience that man comes to know about the world, and it is from this experience that judgments are derived.
Some further comments on cultural relativism1 herskovits. Herskovits debunks the longstanding myth that the remnant of the african diaspora in the americas are without a cultural past. African studies was herskovits discussion of the cattle complex in east africa which formed the. His tendency was to minimize, though not ignore, the influence of national or global forces on culture and emphasize endogenous development. Herskovits 4 editions first published in 1947 download daisy. Melville herskovits 18951963 was an anthropologist most wellknown for his study the myth of the negro past. Baixe no formato pdf, txt ou leia online no scribd. Cross cultural adaption was first put forward by american anthropologist robert redfield, the main representatives of american cultural personality, ralph linton and melville herskovits in the early 20. He also considered himself to beand i think he was a. Herskovits was a champion of cultural relativism, which he saw as an antidote to european colonial attitudes and the ethnocentrism that they express. In herskovits article, he talks about how cultural relativism is such a controversial study.
Any embellishment of ordinary living that is achieved with competence and has describable form 1955. Herskovits cultural relativism and cultural values september 25, 20 sharindeva 2 comments morality is a universal this is the statement that, for me, summarized the entire reading. Tolerance in a repugnant world and other dilemmas in the cultural. Some further comments on cultural relativism melville j. Herskovits is one of the early masters in this concept. Americans in the united states were viewed and viewed themselves.
There he established the first program in african studies at a major u. Sep 18, 20 cultural relativism can be portrayed by the opposite of ethnocentrism. Even the most well trained individuals tend to look at other cultural societies and ideas through the filter of their own morals, and sense of what is right, good. In herskovits time, when the meltingpot theory was still regarded as valid and a highly desirable outcome, one could interpret herskovits theories as saying that africanamericans were resistant to assimilation, and. It may be, as james fernandez 1990 has argued, that the portrait of herskovitss relativism conveyed in these books and essays misinterprets many aspects of what he was trying to convey. In his book, the myth of the negro past, melville j. Publication date 1938 topics acculturation, ethnology publisher new york, j. It may be, as james fernandez 1990 has argued, that the portrait of herskovitss relativism conveyed in these books and essays misinterprets many. In the passage, cultural relativism and cultural values, melville herskovits explains why morality has no absolute identity and that it is a social and cultural phenomenon that varies according to the customs and beliefs of different cultural groups 2. Herskovits cultural relativism and cultural values september 25, 20 sharindeva 2 comments morality is a universal this is the. Herskovits at the heart of blackness documentary film. He is known for exploring the cultural continuity from african cultures as expressed in africanamerican communities. Herskovits at the heart of blackness examines the life and work of the jewishamerican anthropologist, melville herskovits, whose writings challenged prevailing notions of race and culture. It was established as axiomatic in anthropological research by franz boas in the first few decades of the 20th century and later popularized by his students.
105 1049 1281 138 552 1027 821 493 1202 622 1531 1038 619 1009 676 594 320 1554 749 463 616 1286 663 1451 200 900 255 831 1384 205 611 1069 237 1036 1001 535 12 538